Wrestlers who didn't do as well as you thought they would?

[Brandon]

I was going to reply to Burke's other thread jokingly saying that he probably would have gotten more hits if he'd made this the topic instead, but then I thought, I'll just steal the idea for myself!

With their physiques, I really would have thought Drew McIntyre and EC3 would be total masturbation fodder for Vince, and they'd be doing better than Shane's henchman and a comedy act. I also thought Bobby Roode would have done much better than he has.

Same with Mandy Rose. With her look, I'm surprised she hasn't gotten any substantial push beyond the odd title match she obviously wasn't winning. I figured she'd have gotten Lacey Evans' current push by now.

[Burke]

I thought Elijah Burke would have had a career like The Miz. Constantly being high in the midcard and occasional World title feuds.

After winning the title in her debut I thought Gail Kim would have been a staple for years to come.

I was sure they would have put the world title on Chris Masters at least once.

[Brandon]

Jun 25, 2019 12:55:16 GMT -5 Burke said:

I thought Elijah Burke would have had a career like The Miz. Constantly being high in the midcard and occasional World title feuds.

!

I mean I guess we know why he wasn’t, but he really could have been a success.

[Burke]

How did I forget Mistico/original Sin Cara. He's my number one.

I was so hyped when he debuted and thought he was going to be great and eventually pull a Rey Mysterio and move up to the main event. Instead he was a botch machine, released a t-shirt with a penis on it and left after accomplishing pretty much nothing.