PWI Female 50 2012

[Deleted]

Here is the complete list.

1. Gail Kim
2. Beth Phoenix
3. Cheerleader Melissa
4. Sara Del Rey
5. Jessicka Havok
6. Layla
7. Miss Tessmacher
8. Saraya Knight
9. Mercedes Martinez
10. Tara
11. Hailey Hatred
12. Natalya
13. Jazz
14. Velvet Sky
15. Madison Rayne
16. Mickie James
17. LuFisto
18. Winter
19. Tamina Snuka
20. MsChif
21. ODB
22. Eve Torres
23. Kelly Kelly
24. Brittney Savage
25. Melanie Cruise
26. Kellie Skater
27. Sarita
28. Athena
29. Nicole Matthews
30. Paige
31. Angelina Love
32. Portia Perez
33. Rosita
34. Jessie McKay
35. Kalamity
36. Alicia Fox
37. Tasha Simone
38. Taeler Hendrix
39. Rachel Summerlyn
40. Kacee Carlisle
41. Sassy Stephie
42. Cherry Bomb
43. Allysin Kay
44. Alicia
45. Brittany Force
46. Lexxus
47. Marti Belle
48. Amber O’Neal
49. Leva Bates
50. Veda Scott
==========================
I'm in the minority who doesn't feel Gail deserved to be #1 and all it does is feed her ego even more.

Kelly should have been higher and the Bellas should have been on the list. I also don't see how Layla ranked so high considering she was out for like a year. There are some other things about this list I'm SMH about but at least Velvet made into the top 20.

[Tarry]

Oct 19, 2012 13:52:30 GMT -5 @zino said:

8. Saraya Knight
30. Paige

What? Britani/Paige is much better than her mother, seriously.

[jayzero42690]

That list is all kinds of fail

[Brandon]

These lists always confuse me. Are they based on wrestling talent, or is it just a matter of who had the most successful year?

If it's based on who had the most successful year, I can admit that Gail deserves it. If it's based on wrestling talent, I can still admit that Gail deserves it.

Natalya is extremely high for my liking considering the high point of her year was a farting gimmick. Eve should be higher.

[Burke]

I thought Jazz was retired. Unless that's someone else using the same name.

These lists never make any sense to me. They need to either make it completely kayfabe or just who they feel are the best wrestlers. Trying to create a mixture of both just ends up being a mess.

As far as wrestling ability goes, I'll give Gail credit, she's probably my all-time fave diva if I was just going by in-ring. She never had any kind of personality to really reach my top tier of overall favourites though.

[Tarry]

I think it's a list based on kayfabe accomplishments and whatnot, but with some obvious bias thrown in too.

[Angelwings]

I wouldn't worry about it zin. As Tarry said, it's apparently based largely on who held titles the most during the past year. Recall McCool won it a few years ago when she had her long run too.

I don't really agree with Gail either as the division has regressed in importance and entertainment under her wing. (Not all her fault, but still.) Then again women's wrestling/sports entertainment in the two biggest feds is a shell of what it was in pretty much any other time from the turn of the century foward. So what can you do.

Oct 19, 2012 14:48:18 GMT -5 Burke said:

I thought Jazz was retired. Unless that's someone else using the same name.

She actually still works some indy shows. Nonetheless she's too high here but that list is full of errors too numerous to bother picking apart.